______the exam,the boy was punished by his father.A.No passing B.Having passed C.Not passing D.Not having passed答案应该选D,为什么不能选C?

______the exam,the boy was punished by his father.
A.No passing B.Having passed
C.Not passing D.Not having passed
答案应该选D,为什么不能选C?

强调这两个动作的发生顺序,由于考试没过,他爸爸才惩罚了他,考试没过这个动作先发生,用完成时体现

这一看就是个过去完成时啊 因为考试失败已经发生在他爸打他之前 过去的过去

要用完成时，因为没有参加考试这个动作 是发生在被父亲惩罚这个动作之前，